The Mess of Pottage
- 01Theme: Pro-rata survived on custom, and the market has outgrown the custom
- 02Theme: Capital concentration and megafund stage creep are driving the conflict
- 03Theme: Pro-rata's value is concentrated in early follow-ons, which is exactly what megafunds want
- 04Theme: The legal and contractual protections have steadily eroded
1. Key Themes
Theme: Pro-rata survived on custom, and the market has outgrown the custom
Insight: Pro-rata rights were never really enforceable, so they worked only as an "honour system"
"Everybody knows pro rata rights are valuable, but it's equally well known that they're basically unenforcable because no VC firm wants to sue a founder. So, this supposedly professional industry has operated on an opaque 'honour system'..." — Dan Gray
The authors add: "Pro-rata survived on vibes and good manners, becoming peculiar custom in VC."
Insight: Honour systems have a size limit, and venture has likely passed it
The authors use the NYSE's fixed commission cartel as the parallel. It lasted from 1792 to 1975 and broke when institutions outgrew the brokers.
"An honour system needs 3 things to work: 1. People have to expect to meet again. 2. No player should be big enough to make breaking the rules worth it. 3. For reputation to mean anything, people have to remember who broke their word. Venture in 2026 has lost all 3."
"The fairness of the custom was never an issue and had little to do with its downfall. The biggest players had simply grown big enough that breaking the rules paid better than playing along."
Theme: Capital concentration and megafund stage creep are driving the conflict
Insight: A handful of megafunds dominate capital, and they now compete at early stage
"Funds of $500M or more raised 76% of the quarter's venture dollars while making up only 17% of the funds. Bessemer's $5.75B fundraise alone was larger than all 86 emerging funds that closed that quarter combined."
"54% of US venture dollars in 2025 went in at valuations above $1B, against 4% in 2006."
"The average firm is almost 8 times bigger than the median one... $296M against $38M."
Insight: Big funds now arrive early with specific ownership targets
"a16z went from around 17 early-stage deals a year in 2015–19 to 77 in the AI era. At Sequoia, early-stage investments went from less than 20% of its deals to nearly 50%."
"Big funds now come in much earlier, often with a pretty specific ownership target in mind."
Insight: The ask for a waiver is structural, because a full pro-rata leaves too little for the lead
"Virtually no growth investor can lead a round for 1.5% of a company." — Austen Allred
The authors summarise: "if everyone takes their full pro-rata, there isn't enough left in the round for the lead to get its stake, and without the lead there's no round."
Theme: Pro-rata's value is concentrated in early follow-ons, which is exactly what megafunds want
Insight: Early follow-ons are cheap and carry outsized returns, while later rounds return little
"At its IPO price in July 2025, the seed shares Index bought in 2013 were worth 376x what they cost... Series B shares were worth 100x, Series C shares 30x, and only the 2021 Series E came in under 2x."
"In our numbers the first follow-on was usually cheap enough: in 19 of the 26 companies our $31M fund could take its full pro-rata there for less than a tenth of its reserve."
"A $240K cheque in Airbnb's Series A was worth $77M at the IPO... $660K in DoorDash's Series A turned into $91M... $870K in Facebook's 2006 round into $115M."
"The real money, then, is in the early follow-ons when valuations are still acceptable for emerging fund... And, unsurprisingly, those are the very rounds megafunds that expanded to early stages would rather keep to themselves."
Insight: A small fund cannot hold pro-rata through every round
"In all 9 winners we checked, pro-rata in every round would have cost more than the fund's entire reserve, and in 4 of them more than the entire fund."
"Full pro-rata through every later round would have cost more than the fund's $10M reserve in 22 of the 26 winners, and more than the whole $31M fund in 16."
Keeping 1% of Anthropic cost "$1.3B in 5 years."
Theme: The legal and contractual protections have steadily eroded
Insight: Control of the right moved from the individual investor to the majority
"Unlike Gray, who alone could give up his right, an investor could now lose it because everyone else agreed."
"Majority waivers went from common to almost everywhere, appearing in 76% of recent agreements... spring-back clauses started popping up too, going from just 2% to 44%... only 1 in 8 agreements gives an investor a veto over waiving their own rights."
Insight: Tranched, multi-price rounds give leads a hidden bargain
"Sequoia's Pat Grady said they had done 7 deals at an average $110M valuation, while investors arriving just a month later paid an average $3.4B."
"Ineffable Intelligence's filings is the live example: $1.20 per share in the first tranche, $62.36 in the second. That's 52 times more for the same company."
"Existing VCs are asked to waive pro-rata at the lower valuation, then offered allocation at a higher price in the 'same round.'" — Brayton Williams
2. Contrarian Perspectives
Pro-rata is a fight about the early rounds, not about holding stakes forever
Most debate treats pro-rata as an all-or-nothing right. The authors argue that its value sits in the first follow-ons and that most late-stage pro-rata is not worth exercising.
"Not every winner turns into a decacorn or hectocorn, where even a heavily diluted early stake can make a fund."
"Plus, some of the later rounds were barely worth the trouble. Chime, Navan and Circle all went public below their last private valuations. CoreWeave's last private round did little better, returning just 4%."
"Plus later rounds return least, as we've shown before, seed fund would certainly not exercise pro-rata that late, 16 of the rounds we looked at were priced above the eventual IPO."
They also show that full pro-rata is not necessary to win. USV skipped most of it and still came out ahead:
"USV took its Twitter pro-rata in 2008, barely any in 2009, then let it go, and still owned 5.9% of the company at the IPO, a stake worth about $724M, close to 6 times the USV Fund I."
Both sides of the Valar fight agree that waivers are normal
The public argument framed pro-rata as a sacred right being violated. The authors say the real dispute is narrower.
"Both sides actually agree on one thing: waiving pro-rata is normal. Taylor says a round like this generally calls for it. Bucher says Day One has done it dozens of times, including once for Valar during the Series A extension... The fight is really about whether this time was different, and whether Valar could ask Day One to give up its rights permanently, not just for this round."
The honour system now punishes those who keep their word
"Funny how an honour system that once punished those who broke their word now seems to punish those who insist on keeping it."
This ties to Taylor's point that other investors "cared more about future opportunities than fighting for their allocation." Small funds fear they will not be invited to the next hot round.
Abolishing pro-rata (the Neo approach) will not save small funds
"Neo has already gone that way and dropped long-term pro-rata from its standard deals... Fair enough, though this game is much easier to play when the name of your fund opens doors by itself. For a $30M seed fund competing with Sequoia for the same allocation it does not really solve the issue, every founder would prefer more glamorous investors on their cap table."
3. Companies Identified
Valar Atomics
- Description: Nuclear reactor startup.
- Why mentioned: Central case study, because it sued its own seed investor over pro-rata.
- Quotes: "In October 2026 a nuclear startup sued one of its own seed investors over it." / "the day before closing the holders of a majority of Valar's stock deleted the clause that would have brought those rights back (via spring-back)."
Day One Ventures
- Description: Early-stage VC firm founded by Masha Bucher.
- Why mentioned: The seed investor in the Valar dispute that refused to waive.
- Quotes: "Day One refused to go along and hired Quinn Emanuel, and Valar went to a Delaware court."
Sequoia
- Description: Megafund VC firm.
- Why mentioned: Pre-empted Valar's $1B Series B. Also the main example of a firm moving earlier and using multi-price deals.
- Quotes: "Sequoia pre-empted Valar's $1B Series B." / "At Sequoia, early-stage investments went from less than 20% of its deals to nearly 50%."
Coinbase / Initialized Capital
- Description: Crypto exchange and its seed investor.
- Why mentioned: Illustrates the value of pro-rata.
- Quotes: "Initialized put about $300K in the Coinbase seed, and on the listing day this single cheque was already worth more than $500M... for every 1% of Coinbase an investor held, keeping it in the 2015 Series C cost about $0.75M and was worth about $116M when Coinbase listed."
Figma / Index Ventures
- Description: Design software company and its seed investor.
- Why mentioned: Shows return multiples declining by round, and Index's approach of buying about twice its pro-rata in the cheap early rounds.
- Quotes: "Index bought about twice its pro-rata in the cheap Series A and B from the same fund, and left the expensive later rounds to its growth funds. Index VI's stake was worth $1.95B at the IPO, 4.4x the fund."
Twitter / Union Square Ventures (USV)
- Description: Social network and its early lead investor.
- Why mentioned: Example of a fund that skipped later pro-rata and still won.
- Quotes: "234x for its first venture round, 1.6x for its last." / USV "still owned 5.9% of the company at the IPO."
SpaceX / Founders Fund
- Description: Space company and its first outside investor.
- Why mentioned: Shows the impossibility of holding a stake through every round from a single fund.
- Quotes: "To hold this stake through every round after, Fund II would need to put in 1.4–1.9x of its own size, which is of course impossible for any fund... leaving it with 3.1% of SpaceX, worth $55B."
Cerebras / Eclipse
- Description: AI chip company and its early investor.
- Why mentioned: Another case of following on through side vehicles.
- Quotes: "Eclipse followed on anyway, through a continuity fund and an SPV: $145M in all, for a 7.3% stake worth $2.5B at the IPO."
Bessemer
- Description: Megafund.
- Why mentioned: Used to illustrate the scale gap.
- Quotes: "Bessemer's latest fundraise is about 180 times the median emerging fund in our Q3 data, $5.75B against $31M."
a16z
- Description: Megafund VC firm.
- Why mentioned: Example of megafund expansion into early stage.
- Quotes: "a16z went from around 17 early-stage deals a year in 2015–19 to 77 in the AI era."
Neo
- Description: Venture firm.
- Why mentioned: Early adopter of the "abolish pro-rata" path.
- Quotes: "Neo has already gone that way and dropped long-term pro-rata from its standard deals."
Y Combinator
- Description: Accelerator and SAFE creator.
- Why mentioned: Moved pro-rata from the SAFE to an optional side letter.
- Quotes: "Even Y Combinator, which initially gave investors pro-rata through its SAFE in 2013, moved it to an optional side letter in 2018, admitting that 'it's impossible to create a universal standard for pro rata rights.'"
Ineffable Intelligence
- Description: AI company with a tranched round.
- Why mentioned: Live example of a two-price round.
- Quotes: "$1.20 per share in the first tranche, $62.36 in the second. That's 52 times more for the same company."
Modal and Serval
- Description: Startups with tranched rounds.
- Why mentioned: Cases where an earlier investor existed and missing the cheap tranche had a cost.
- Quotes: "In deals where one did exist, like Modal and Serval, our estimates put the cost of missing the cheap allocation at $1–10M for a 3.3% holder."
Airbnb, DoorDash, Facebook, Google, Cursor, Anthropic
- Description: Winners used to price follow-ons.
- Why mentioned: Cost-of-holding and return illustrations.
- Quotes: "A $240K cheque in Airbnb's Series A was worth $77M at the IPO" / "Keeping 1%... of Cursor, $34M in 2 years... of Anthropic, $1.3B in 5 years."
Airtable, Miro, Chime, Navan, Circle, CoreWeave
- Description: Companies where late rounds underperformed.
- Why mentioned: Evidence that not every winner rewards late-stage pro-rata.
- Quotes: "Chime, Navan and Circle all went public below their last private valuations." / "Remember Airtable and Miro?"
Platform sponsors: Legion, Harmonic, Rings AI, Cura, Wonderstruck
- Description: Tools and services for VCs and LPs.
- Why mentioned: Newsletter sponsors, not analysis.
- Quotes: "Legion is a high-signal marketplace matching emerging GPs with relevant LPs..." / "Harmonic aggregates real-time data on 30M+ companies and 190M+ people..."
4. People Identified
Isaiah Taylor
- Description: Founder of Valar Atomics.
- Why mentioned: His public account triggered the pro-rata debate.
- Quotes: "Letting Day One onto my cap table is the single worst mistake I've made since founding the company. It was very obvious to everyone around me at the time that they would be nothing but trouble, but I was desperate for cash."
Masha Bucher
- Description: Founder of Day One Ventures.
- Why mentioned: The investor on the other side of the dispute.
- Quotes: "Since you have created public interest in this, it is important that people should hear both sides of the story."
Fred Wilson
- Description: USV co-founder and VC commentator.
- Why mentioned: Evolving view of pro-rata, from "single most important term" to "a black mark on the sector." Also proposed warrants as compensation for unhonoured pro-rata.
- Quotes: "the single most important term anyone can negotiate for in a venture capital investment." / "we did not have the funds."
Dan Gray
- Description: Odin, VC commentator.
- Why mentioned: Coined the "honour system" framing and criticised brand-name firms.
- Quotes: "Brand-name firms are manipulating founders into doing their dirty work — getting early investors to waive pro rata."
Jason Lemkin
- Description: SaaStr founder.
- Why mentioned: Pointed out a double standard.
- Quotes: "Notice also that the megafunds asking seed investors to waive never waive their own rights."
Dan Primack
- Description: Axios.
- Why mentioned: Articulated the LP-model argument for pro-rata.
- Quotes: "Without pro rata rights, how does the seed/early model not collapse? Why would LPs fund it?"
Austen Allred
- Description: Founder-investor commentator.
- Why mentioned: Explained the lead's side of the math.
- Quotes: "Virtually no growth investor can lead a round for 1.5% of a company."
Brayton Williams
- Description: Boost VC.
- Why mentioned: Flagged tranched-valuation rounds as the missing piece in the debate.
- Quotes: "Existing VCs are asked to waive pro-rata at the lower valuation, then offered allocation at a higher price in the 'same round.'"
Pat Grady
- Description: Sequoia partner.
- Why mentioned: Confirmed the firm's multi-price deals.
- Quotes: Sequoia "had done 7 deals at an average $110M valuation, while investors arriving just a month later paid an average $3.4B."
Garry Tan
- Description: YC leader and ex-Initialized.
- Why mentioned: Explained why Initialized missed Coinbase follow-ons.
- Quotes: They "didn't always have the capital to push in."
Abe Othman
- Description: AngelList.
- Why mentioned: Research on follow-on returns.
- Quotes: "Seed funds following on consistently earned higher returns on average, but not at the median."
Leo Polovets and Christoph Janz
- Description: VC investors.
- Why mentioned: Proposed time-limited or declining pro-rata.
- Quotes: "Leo Polovets wants it to expire after 1 or 2 rounds, while Christoph Janz suggests shrinking it from 100% to 50% to 25%."
Hunter Walk
- Description: VC investor.
- Why mentioned: Sees pro-rata becoming tradable.
- Quotes: Calls it "a trade as much as an investment."
Trace Cohen
- Description: Investor.
- Why mentioned: Relayed the "you should be grateful" anecdote.
- Quotes: "You should be grateful we are marking you up."
Richard Testa
- Description: Boston lawyer.
- Why mentioned: Early documentation of VC participation rights.
- Quotes: VCs "often insist upon a right to participate in future financings."
Eric Barroca and Bilal Farooqui
- Description: Commenters on X.
- Why mentioned: Voiced counterpoints in the threads.
- Quotes: "It's the calculus of early funds to be able to continue deploy in their winners." (Barroca) / "i wouldn't want day one on my cap table at all but valar seems to have benefited immensely from the relationship." (Farooqui)
5. Operating Insights
For emerging fund managers: negotiate protection against majority waivers, not just the right itself
The vulnerability is that majority waivers can erase everyone's rights.
"Majority waivers can wipe out everyone's rights, as Valar showed. A separately negotiated side letter that protects your specific allocation against majority waiver might be worth more than a promise to the whole cap table."
"Only 1 in 8 agreements gives an investor a veto over waiving their own rights."
Concentrate follow-on capital in the first one or two rounds and price the waiver
Plan reserves around where the multiples are, not around holding ownership forever. When asked to waive, know what it costs.
"Pro-rata gets an expiry date." / "Waivers get a price tag... by our estimates one cheap tranche alone can cost a holder $1–10M, giving it away just like that, for a thank you, seems rather generous."
Index's approach is a template: it "bought about twice its pro-rata in the cheap Series A and B from the same fund, and left the expensive later rounds to its growth funds."
Founders: sequence and document waivers carefully, and check which tranche price pro-rata applies to
Honouring everyone's pro-rata can kill the round, but waivers carry legal and relationship risk.
"Honour everyone's pro-rata and you might lose the round, waive it and you might lose an investor, or end up facing a lawsuit."
Existing investors increasingly ask which price their right allows: "Paying 52x more than the lead for the same company is a hard sell." Founders should settle this in advance rather than the day before closing.
6. Overlooked Insights
LPs are asking whether perpetual pro-rata should exist at all
This got buried in the Valar noise.
"Meanwhile, LPs were having a debate of their own, asking an even bigger question: should VCs have perpetual pro-rata rights at all?"
New-manager fundraising has collapsed, which compounds the squeeze on small funds
"457 first-time US VC funds closed in 2021, compared with just 81 in the first 9 months of 2026."
Fewer new funds mean fewer sources of seed capital, and funds that are squeezed out of their best companies find it harder to raise the next one.