Teahose.
SIGN IN
NEW HERE — WHAT TEAHOSE DOES
We read the entire AI & tech firehose — so you don't have to.
PODPodcastsAll-In, No Priors, Acquired…
NEWNewslettersStratechery, Newcomer…
PAPPapersPhysical AI research
PHProduct Huntdaily launches
VCInvestor ScoutSequoia, a16z, Benchmark…
CLAUDE DISTILLS →
7 reads, 30 sec each — free, 6 AM ET.
+ a live graph of the companies, people & themes underneath.
HOME/THE VC CORNER/Yuri Milner Backed Every YC Star…
NEWS
// NEWSLETTER ISSUE
THE VC CORNER

Yuri Milner Backed Every YC Startup in 2011. Investors Who Index YC Made a 5x Median

DATE November 16, 2026SOURCE THE VC CORNERPARTICIPANTS THE VC CORNER
// SUMMARY

1. Key Themes

Theme: Indexing the YC filter (spreading bets across every batch) has outperformed typical venture funds

The headline return gap

Investors who systematically backed YC Demo Day startups beat the median venture fund by a wide margin.

"Investors who backed at least 3 startups at every YC Demo Day from 2018 to 2020 made a 5x median multiple, according to YC's own study. The median venture fund of those years made 1.1x to 1.6x, per Carta."

Even the weak end of the YC cohort competes with the best funds

"The bottom quarter of YC Demo Day investors made 3.3x. That beats the top 10% of US funds from the 2019, 2020 and 2021 vintages, and the YC median of 5x beats the top 10% of every vintage shown."

Milner's edge was consistency, not selection

The strategy worked because he refused to skip any batch.

"Milner's edge was staying in every batch, which is the part most investors skip."

Theme: Venture returns are extremely power-law, which is why breadth matters

A handful of unicorns produce nearly all the cash

"Heyman also found that unicorns produce about 93% of the cash returned to YC seed investors. Every return in this asset class comes from a handful of companies per batch, and you have to own them to get it."

Missing a batch can mean missing the decade-defining company

"An investor who skips a batch can miss the one company that pays for the decade."

YC's filter raises unicorn odds well above seed averages

"Of the ones that get in, 4.5% become unicorns by Palle Broe's count in Lenny's Newsletter and 6.5% by Orange Collective's, against 2.5% for the average seed startup." (Context: "10,000+ startups apply every quarter and about 1% get in.")

Theme: YC's deal terms keep getting more founder-friendly and standardized, with investor-friendly entry for outside capital

YC's check grew 25x while its price per startup fell

"In 2008 YC invested under $20,000 for about 6%... Today YC invests $500,000: $125,000 for 7% on a post-money SAFE plus $375,000 on an uncapped MFN SAFE."

"When YC moved to $500,000 in January 2022, it tripled the money and cut its own price per startup by 17%, from a $2.14M implied post-money to $1.79M."

The uncapped structure originated with Milner

"Three quarters of the check is now uncapped, the same structure Milner used, with YC taking his seat."

Theme: Outcome variance by batch is huge, so timing/vintage risk is the real danger

Same strategy, 24x spread in outcomes

"The Winter 2019 fund sits at 11.45x, Winter 2018 at 9.88x, and Summer 2016 at 0.47x. Same strategy, and the outcome swung 24-fold depending on which six months you showed up."


2. Contrarian Perspectives

Perspective 1: Buying the filter beats picking the company

Milner had already put $200M into Facebook, yet he chose to back an entire cohort sight unseen rather than a single startup.

  • Evidence: "Then they made an offer to all 43 startups at once: $150,000 each, on a convertible note with no valuation cap and no discount, before Milner had seen most of the companies. By 3 p.m. the next day, 39 had signed."
  • "Milner's DST had put $200 million into Facebook two years earlier, and here he was buying YC's filter instead of any single startup."
  • Reasoning: Since returns come from a few outliers ("unicorns produce about 93% of the cash returned"), diversification across the filter captures them better than conviction-based selection.

Perspective 2: The author is skeptical of the headline stat he's promoting

Unusually, the author cautions against taking the 5x figure at face value, even while believing the direction holds.

"Here's where I'm skeptical. These are YC's own numbers, repeated by funds that sell YC exposure, and I'd want an independent audit before quoting them in an LP letter. They also compare angel portfolios marked at the latest round against funds reporting after fees, so the gap is wider on paper than in a bank account."

  • Reasoning: Independent data (AngelList's Demo Day funds) points the same direction, but the real-world gap is likely narrower than reported.

Perspective 3: Data sources disagree meaningfully on how many YC unicorns become decacorns

"The decacorn question splits the sources most. Orange Collective says 25% of YC unicorns reach $10B. Jared Heyman's 2022 count found about a dozen among 101 unicorns, closer to 12%."

  • Reasoning: A 2x discrepancy in the top-tail rate suggests investors should haircut promotional figures from funds that sell YC exposure.

3. Companies Identified

Y Combinator

  • Description: Leading startup accelerator
  • Why mentioned: Central subject; its selectivity and deal terms drive the thesis
  • Quotes: "10,000+ startups apply every quarter and about 1% get in." / "Today YC invests $500,000..."

DST Global (Yuri Milner)

  • Description: Investment firm of Yuri Milner
  • Why mentioned: Funded the Start Fund; earlier $200M Facebook investment
  • Quotes: "Milner's DST had put $200 million into Facebook two years earlier."

SV Angel

  • Description: Seed investor, co-sponsor of the Start Fund
  • Why mentioned: Co-led the 2011 blanket offer; later stepped out of YC VC
  • Quotes: "SV Angel stepped out, and Khosla Ventures took Milner's seat in December 2013."

Khosla Ventures

  • Description: Venture firm
  • Why mentioned: Took Milner's seat in YC VC
  • Quotes: "Khosla Ventures took Milner's seat in December 2013."

a16z, General Catalyst, Maverick

  • Description: Venture investors
  • Why mentioned: Co-participants in YC VC at $20,000 each
  • Quotes: "$80,000 per startup, $20,000 each from Milner, a16z, General Catalyst and Maverick."

Coinbase, Instacart, Gusto, DoorDash

  • Description: YC alumni that became major companies
  • Why mentioned: Examples of outcomes from the batches covered by automatic offers
  • Quotes: "Those batches produced Coinbase and Instacart (both Summer 2012), Gusto (Winter 2012) and DoorDash (Summer 2013)."

Carta

  • Description: Cap table/fund data provider
  • Why mentioned: Benchmark for US venture fund returns (2,906 funds)
  • Quotes: "The median venture fund of those years made 1.1x to 1.6x, per Carta."

AngelList (Demo Day funds)

  • Description: Investing platform
  • Why mentioned: Independent net-return data by batch
  • Quotes: "AngelList's Demo Day funds publish net returns by batch."

Orange Collective

  • Description: Fund/data source focused on YC startups
  • Why mentioned: Source of unicorn/decacorn rates and return data
  • Quotes: "...6.5% by Orange Collective's, against 2.5% for the average seed startup."

GR Angel

  • Description: Angel vehicle run by the author and Guillermo Flor
  • Why mentioned: Author's own YC-indexing strategy
  • Quotes: "we back 5 startups from every YC batch"; "5 startups per batch, with 53+ companies backed and a first exit."

Lenny's Newsletter

  • Description: Publication
  • Why mentioned: Source of Palle Broe's YC unicorn count
  • Quotes: "4.5% become unicorns by Palle Broe's count in Lenny's Newsletter."

4. People Identified

Yuri Milner

  • Description: Investor, founder of DST
  • Why mentioned: Backed every YC startup from 2011; the case study for the thesis
  • Quotes: "Milner's edge was staying in every batch, which is the part most investors skip."

David Lee (SV Angel)

  • Description: Investor at SV Angel
  • Why mentioned: Explained the logic of the offer to TechCrunch
  • Quotes: "'These aren't gifts, we're not a charity.'"

Ruben Dominguez

  • Description: Author; runs GR Angel and The VC Corner
  • Why mentioned: Author with skin in the game
  • Quotes: "I have skin in this."

Guillermo Flor

  • Description: Co-runs GR Angel
  • Why mentioned: Partner in the YC-indexing strategy
  • Quotes: "Guillermo Flor and I run GR Angel, and we back 5 startups from every YC batch."

Jared Heyman

  • Description: Researcher/investor who analyzes YC outcomes
  • Why mentioned: Source on unicorn cash-return concentration and decacorn rate
  • Quotes: "Heyman also found that unicorns produce about 93% of the cash returned to YC seed investors."

Palle Broe

  • Description: Analyst published in Lenny's Newsletter
  • Why mentioned: Source of the 4.5% YC unicorn rate
  • Quotes: "4.5% become unicorns by Palle Broe's count in Lenny's Newsletter."

5. Operating Insights

1. Commit to a systematic, every-batch cadence rather than opportunistic picking

  • Fixed allocation per batch (e.g., GR Angel's 5 per batch) removes timing bias, which matters given the 24x batch-to-batch swing.
  • "Milner's edge was staying in every batch, which is the part most investors skip."

2. Run a structured checklist before every SAFE and benchmark caps

  • The playbook offers a repeatable diligence process rather than gut feel.
  • "The 10-point Demo Day checklist to run before every SAFE, with the 2026 cap benchmarks."

3. Size your portfolio to your target probability of catching a unicorn

  • Check count should be derived from math, not budget alone.
  • "how many YC companies you need to hold for a 50%, 75% or 90% chance of owning a unicorn, and what it costs at three check sizes."

6. Overlooked Insights

1. YC effectively reduced its own price while increasing check size, signaling confidence in volume/outlier economics

  • Raising to $500K and lowering implied post-money from $2.14M to $1.79M means YC is trading ownership dilution risk for stronger access to the cohort.
  • "it tripled the money and cut its own price per startup by 17%."

2. Low-minimum access exists, widening who can index YC

  • Retail-sized entry points ("from $5,000 Demo Day funds to direct checks") suggest the strategy is no longer limited to institutions, but fees/access rules vary and are the paywalled detail worth scrutinizing.
  • "7 ways to get YC exposure in 2026, with minimums, fees, access rules and who each one fits, from $5,000 Demo Day funds to direct checks."